It is important to clarify that just providing Kanban boards as a feature is not enough to classify a tool as Kanban software.
The boards associated with the Kanban method have become part of almost every project management software out there, including Jira. However, although it is a fantastic management solution, in its essence, Jira is not designed to be a Kanban software.
Let’s see how it compares to Kanbanize regarding the six core practices of Kanban:
|Limit work in progress||✔||✔|
|Make policies explicit||✔|
|Establish feedback loops||✔||✔|
|Seek continuous improvement||✔||✔|
From a basic comparison like the one in the table above, it would seem like there’s no big difference between Jira and Kanbanize. However, if you dig deeper, you will understand that Jira is just scratching the surface of the Kanban method and can facilitate only a shallow implementation.
To clearly prove that, we will use the Kanban Maturity Model (KMM) as a basis for comparison. If this is the first time you are hearing about the KMM, you must know that it consists of 7 organizational maturity levels that break down the 6 core practices of the Kanban method into 132 sub-practices depending on the level of experience with the method.
The next table is a very clear proof why Kanbanize is the best Jira alternative if you seek a tool supporting mature Kanban implementation.
|Visualize an individual’s work by means of a personal Kanban board||✔||✔|
|Visualize basic work item related information on a ticket||✔||✔|
|Visualize work for several individuals by means of an aggregated personal Kanban board||✔||✔|
|Visualize the work carried out by a team by means of a team Kanban board||✔||✔|
|Use avatars to visualize an individual’s workload||✔||✔|
|Visualize initial policies||✔|
|Visualize teamwork by means of an emergent workflow Kanban board||✔|
|Visualize work items on Kanban board with per-person WIP limits||✔||✔|
|Visualize work types by means of card colors or board rows||✔||✔|
|Visualize blocked work items||✔|
|Visualize development of options by means of a discovery Kanban board||✔||✔|
|Visualize individual workload on a discovery Kanban board by means of per-person WIP limits, potentially implemented using avatars||✔|
|Visualize basic policies||✔|
|Ticket design: Visualize concurrent or unordered activities with checkboxes||✔||✔|
|Ticket design: Visualize concurrent activities performed by specialist teams using partial rows||✔|
|Board design: Visualize sequential activities where no dependency or preferred sequence exists using rows or vertical spaces||✔|
|Visualize defects and other rework types||✔||✔|
|Visualize workflow by means of enhanced discovery/delivery boards||✔||✔|
|Visualize project progress on a portfolio Kanban board||✔|
|Visualize “ready to commit” status, also known as “ready to pull”||✔||✔|
|Visualize “ready to pull” criteria, also known as “definition of ready”, “entry criteria”||✔||✔|
|Visualize workflow and teamwork items on one Kanban board||✔||✔|
|Visualize project work items on a two-tiered project Kanban board||✔|
|Visualize parent-child and peer-peer dependencies||✔||✔|
|Use parking lot to visualize dependent work requests of another service or system currently waiting or blocked||✔|
|Visualize upstream options by means of an upstream/discovery Kanban board||✔||✔|
|Visualize discarded options using a bin on an upstream/ discovery Kanban board||✔||✔|
|Visualize replenishment signals||✔|
|Visualize pull signals||✔|
|Visualize pull criteria (also known as “pull policies”, “definition of ready”, “exit criteria”)||✔|
|Visualize available capacity||✔|
|Visualize work item aging||✔|
|Visualize target date or SLA||✔||✔|
|Visualize failure demand versus value demand|
|Visualize aborted work||✔||✔|
|Visualize class of service using ticket colors, board rows or ticket decorators||✔||✔|
|Use Earned Value portfolio Kanban board to visualize project progress and schedule or budget risk||✔|
|Visualize local cycle time|
|Use ticket decorators to indicate risks||✔||✔|
|Visualize risk classes with different swimlanes||✔||✔|
As you can see, there’s a lot more to workflow visualization than setting up a few columns on your Kanban board and starting to move cards.
Considering everything from the table above, if you decide to choose Kanbanize as the best Jira alternative, you will be able to visualize blocked items, which is among the most useful things in Kanban that allows you to quickly solve problems when they arise.
Also, you will be able to put constant light on process policies by visualizing them directly on your board, and indicate that your team needs to replenish the number of assignments that await to be started.
Going over the most fundamental functionalities, it is important to point out that with Kanbanize you can visualize aging work items that have been in progress for a while and take action to prevent a potentially harmful situation for your company.
Limiting Work in Progress
|Establish personal WIP limits||✔|
|Establish per person WIP limits||✔|
|Establish team WIP limits||✔||✔|
|Establish activity based WIP limits||✔||✔|
|Establish CONWIP limits on emergent workflow||✔|
|Use an order point (min limit) for upstream replenishment||✔||✔|
|Use a max limit to define capacity||✔||✔|
|Bracket WIP limits for different states||✔|
Limiting work in progress is vital for keeping your team focused and delivering value in the shortest amount of time to your customers. Although Jira covers a few of the ways, it lacks capability regarding limiting WIP on a personal level, and process levels.
Nonetheless, the system doesn’t allow you to set unbreakable limits, which can lead to frequent process inefficiency.
|Define work types based on the nature of tasks||✔||✔|
|Define work types based on customer requests||✔||✔|
|Map upstream and downstream flow||✔||✔|
|Manage blocking issues||✔|
|Manage defects and other rework types||✔||✔|
|Organize around the knowledge discovery process|
|Use a cumulative flow diagram to monitor queues||✔||✔|
|Report rudimentary flow efficiency to understand the value of reducing buffers and the leverage of eliminating sources of delay||✔|
|Collect and report detailed flow efficiency analysis||✔|
|Determine the reference class data set||✔|
|Forecast using reference classes, Monte Carlo simulations and other models||✔|
|Allocate capacity across swimlanes|
|Allocate capacity by the color of a work item|
|Make appropriate use of forecasting||✔|
|Assess forecasting models for robustness|
When it comes to flow management, Kanbanize clearly is a better Jira alternative regarding Kanban, because it allows you to manage blockers, in addition to visualizing them. Nonetheless, you can measure and report the flow efficiency of your process, which is among the most important metrics in Kanban.
Using Monte Carlo simulations, you can forecast future performance based on historical data and commit to deadlines with more confidence.
Make Policies Explicit
|Define personal Kanban policies||✔|
|Define Initial Policies||✔|
|Define initial services||✔||✔|
|Elaborate further policies||✔|
|Define blocking issue escalation policies||✔|
|Define policies for managing defects and other rework types||✔|
|Establish initial request acceptance policies||✔|
|Define work request abandonment policies||✔|
|Establish replenishment commitment point||✔||✔|
|Establish pull criteria||✔|
|Establish a delivery commitment point||✔||✔|
|Define classes of service||✔||✔|
|Collect and report detailed flow efficiency analysis||✔|
|Establish demand shaping policies|
Process policies are like playbooks in professional sports. You define them to keep your team aware of how to act in certain situations. The more explicit you make them, the less chance for mistakes and process inefficiencies.
Establish Feedback Loops
Focusing on the tool agnostic part of maintaining feedback loops, once again, Kanbanize proves to be a better Jira alternative.
|Ability to leave comments||✔||✔|
|Cycle Time Scatterplot||✔|
|Cycle Time Histogram||✔|
|Throughput Run Chart||✔|
|WIP Run Chart||✔|
|Aging WIP Chart||✔|
|Flow Efficiency Chart||✔|
|Monte Carlo Simulations||✔|
Primary Strengths of Kanbanize
Out of every comparison so far, there are a few fundamental strengths of Kanbanize regarding Kanban, which deserve special attention.
You can make policies explicit
Your process policies are your workflow’s law. You establish them to work in the most efficient way possible and visualize them on your project boards so your team can see them all the time.
In Kanban, policies can be placed anywhere on the board. The goal is to make it explicitly clear what’s expected to happen at any stage of your workflow.
You can design flexible Kanban boards
Jira’s version of the Kanban board is rather limiting. You can create as many columns as you need, but when it comes to swimlanes, your hands are pretty much tied. The system allows you to create swimlanes based only on preset criteria such as assignees, projects, and a handful of other options.
Kanbanize is a Jira alternative to consider if you want flexibility and simplicity. You can design your boards the way you want them. Adding as many swimlanes as you need is just the top of the iceberg.
In addition, you can merge both columns and swimlanes to create a layout that perfectly fits your needs. On top of that, this is done with just a few clicks thanks to the flexible workflow designer inside.
You can visualize blocked work
Visualizing blocked items is a basic feature of every Kanban software, which once again brings up the point that Jira is not one.
The alternative that Kanbanize provides allows you to visualize blockers with a variety of customizable avatars and create as many block reasons as you need. Afterward, you can use methods such as blocker clustering to identify frequently occurring problems and analyze how they damage your process.
You can automate your process
Another serious advantage that Kanbanize has is an automation engine. It allows you to automate large parts of your process with the help of business rules. Basically, you set up hooks that trigger actions when certain events occur.
You can manage a project portfolio with ease
When managing a project portfolio, you need to have absolute transparency and simple visualization of all the dependencies between assignments that comprise it. Although both platforms are equipped with features for this purpose, Kanbanize is a better alternative to Jira.
With Kanbanize, you can enjoy a user-friendly visualization for business teams, not only for dev teams. Everyone can collaborate in Kanbanize.
The platform provides greater flexibility when connecting dependencies by allowing the following task relations:
- Parent – Child
- Predecessor – Successor
With their help, you can break down large initiatives and connect the different aspects that comprise them. Even better, you can specify the order of processing and improve the execution handling.
Transitioning to Kanbanize
If what you’ve read so far has convinced you to choose Kanbanize as an alternative to Jira, we encourage you to check out our product knowledge base. There you will find an extensive archive of feature tutorials and explanations.
In case you are currently using Jira and are wondering how to make the transition, rest assured transitioning is not difficult.
Both platforms use very similar terminology and when it comes to Kanban implementation, there’s nothing you can do in Jira that is unavailable in Kanbanize. Here is a basic comparison regarding the glossary of both products:
Unfortunately, when you decide to switch, there’s a bit of manual work waiting for you. Currently, Jira has very limited capability related to exporting data from its system.
The good news is that in the next couple of months we will be releasing a brand new integration that will allow you to create bidirectional sync between Jira and Kanbanize. With its help, you will be able to transfer data between the systems.
In the meantime, to remap your process from Jira in Kanbanize, you need to create your account and replicate your projects and boards.
There’s an extensive onboarding process, which will help get acquainted with the platform and answer some of the most frequently asked questions that may arise in the process.
Afterward, you can recreate your familiar workspace and continue with your duties.
In addition, our team is always ready to assist so just drop us a message, and we will contact you shortly.
Although it is a fantastic management solution, in its essence, Jira is not designed to be a Kanban software. If you are looking for an alternative to help you implement the Kanban method to its full extent, Kanbanize might be just the right fit. Try it out for free and feel the difference.